BTS’ Vocal Analysis: Jungkook

Jungkook

Vocal Range

G2 ~ Bb5 (3 Octaves, 1 note and 1 semitone)

Supported Range

Eb3/E3 ~ Eb4/E4

Voice Type

Light Lyric Tenor

Strengths/Achievements

  • Second strongest vocalist in BTS
  • The most relaxed singing technique out of all tenors in BTS
  • Pitch is relatively good when not doing vocal runs
  • Tends to favor falsetto over mixed voice, minimizing vocal strain
  • Shallow support is present to an extent in his singing
  • His lower range maintains sufficient connection down to Eb3
  • His middle voice maintains a relaxed approach up to Eb4/E4
  • Falsetto can be relaxed at times
  • Transitions into falsetto are relatively well done

Weaknesses

  • Tends to favor style over technique, completely limiting the development of his voice
  • Tends to sing with a lot of breathiness in tone, not allowing his vocal cords to be connected completely
  • Lower range is often very soft and whispered, lacking developing
  • Mixed voice is very underdeveloped, often has to falsetto when unable to mix properly
  • His larynx raises early on after his first passaggio, around F4
  • Tends to place his voice in his nose and sound very whiny
  • Unable to support with consistency, breathing is almost completely neglected
  • Falsetto can sometimes be flat due to too much airiness
  • Vocal runs are often messy and pitchy
  • Unable to use a head voice with support

Registers

  • Lower register: Most of his lower range is underdeveloped as he doesn’t generally tend to sing too low or too high. His chest voice maintains projection below Eb3, but support is only present down to Eb3. Below that, his voice lacks clarity in tone and becomes quieter.
  • Mixed register: His mixed voice is mostly on the head-dominant side, as he sings with a soft approach most of the time. Very early on in range he starts to sing with a tight throat and a high larynx, even as low as F4.
  • Upper register: In a way, his most developed register. His falsetto is where he seems most comfortable, as he tends to switch to falsetto very early on in his range. Nonetheless, this register still lacks proper support and development overall.

Agility

Jungkook shows that most of his influences come from singing R&B music and that’s where he seems to be most comfortable in terms of genre. As such, he takes a liking to adding his own musical ideas to songs and they’re usually in the form of vocal runs. He has the tendency to add them in many occasions, as he seems to have confidence in this area of his voice. However, due to his young age and to an extent lack of patience, there is a lack of clarity and development of his agility. When it comes to the flexibility of his voice, Jungkook actually possesses the correct muscle memory and rhythmic bounce to clearly sing through different notes in simple trills, as long as they’re short and simple, as heard in “I Need a Girl.” Unfortunately, he tends to add overly complicated runs to many of his vocal performances, which lack precision and accuracy overall. His vocal runs often sound rushed, as he’s unable to sing the notes as quickly as he needs to. Thus instead of taking the time to practice vocal runs slowly first and then speeding them up to the correct speed, his runs often sound like they’re mostly improvised and thus not carefully thought-through. The result is usually sloppy runs that lack a clear idea of key center, as he adds too many notes that don’t necessarily fit in terms of pitch. This can be heard in many occasions, such as in “Sofa“, “Paper Hearts“, “뻔한 멜로디“, “Boyfriend“, “눈, 코, 입“, “Love is not Over“, “You’re My“, “Miss Right” and “If You.”

Overall analysis

Jungkook debuted in 2013 as the main vocalist of Bangtan Boys, more commonly known by international fans as BTS. He is one of the four members of the main vocal line, three tenors and one baritone. The group debuted as mostly a hip-hop based group where most of the focus of their music is on rapping as opposed to singing. As such, a lot of their songs are mostly rapped verses with hook choruses sung by the four members of the vocal line. Jungkook’s voice stands out with a very smooth and mellow timbre. His voice is light and bright, as well as very soft in quality which is often enhanced by many of his stylistic choices. Although not often singing very high, his voice lies in a generally higher range and he would most likely be classified as a light lyric tenor.

The lower part of his chest voice is often neglected and not truly showcased through BTS’ music. As their songs are focused mostly on hooks for the vocalists, the range they’re written in is usually narrow in order to keep the listener hooked in. Thus Jungkook is unable to explore a wide part of his range when singing BTS’ music. Most of the time he stays within a relatively comfortable range and doesn’t sing below D3. This has caused him to often lose projection of his voice when he does need to sing anywhere below an Eb3. As low as E3 and Eb3, he often sounds comfortable as his vocal cords are able to come together and his voice projects without much trouble, as heard in “Sofa“, “Love is not Over” and “샤방샤방.” However, as soon as he sings below Eb3, his vocal cords lack the strength to remain together and his chest voice starts to become breathier and quieter. This can be heard with the B2’s in “Paper Hearts“, “Fools” and G2’s in “나그대에게 모두 드리리.”

Due to his stylistic choices, Jungkook often employs a very unique approach to his singing. He never tries to paint himself as a powerhouse vocalist and uses the natural smoothness of his voice to his advantage. Instead of mixing and belting high, he often sings softly and with a lot of breathiness in tone throughout most of his range. Not only that, but in order to maintain the smoothness and softness in his singing style, he often chooses to sing with his falsetto as opposed to mixing and thus has yet to create the correct muscle memory and development of his mixed voice. For the most part, his mixed voice is quite light in tone and lacks power. His mixing technique relies on a more head-dominant approach and a lot less on his chest voice, which helps him maintain a smooth soft tone overall. Stylistically, it fits exactly the way he intends it to.

However due to him being unable to develop his mixed voice properly and by using too much breathiness in his singing, his larynx tends to be raised much earlier than a more developed tenor would. He actually often mixes quite low and is not known for being a very high belter. Most of the time his mix only goes up to F#4 in their repertoire, only occasionally singing up G4 and G#4. When he sings up to Eb4 and E4, he sounds mostly relaxed and is able to maintain some support, even if it may be shallow and lack depth. However anywhere above E4, his larynx raises and his throat starts to become tight, which results in a mostly whiny tone production. His voice is unable to escape the tension, causing him to sound thin and closed above E4. This can be heard when contrasting the C#4’s in “양화대교“, D4’s in “모릎“, “Fools“, Eb4’s in “See Through“, “뻔한 멜로디” and E4’s in “心中的日月“, with the F4’s in “Coffee“, “Butterfly“, “Miss Right“, F#4’s in “샤방샤방“, “Let Me Know“, “Love is Not Over” “Tomorrow“, “Lost Stars“, G4’s in “See You Again“, “눈, 코, 입“, G#4’s in “I Need U“, “잡아줘” and Bb4’s in “Bang Bang Bang“, “If You” and “Perfect Man.”

His falsetto register is, relatively speaking, his most developed register. He seems to be the most comfortable in this register and is able to transition into it much earlier in range than most tenors would. While many tenors would rather mix up to A4 at least while singing, Jungkook will opt to use falsetto even as low as F#4 while phrasing songs, as heard in “Too Much“, “모릎.” Most of the time, Jungkook choses to use a falsetto over his head voice, by maintaining his vocal cords somewhat separated and allowing air to come through, creating a breathy sound that mostly works stylistically. He is able to use a head voice as well and has done so a handful of times. However due to his inability to grasp breath support properly, even when singing in his head voice, he is unable to maintain a neutral larynx and properly supported tone production. The lack of support in his upper register usually causes him to lose control of his voice and make him sound somewhat pitchy and/or flat. His head voice is thus quite pushed and loud, lacking in control of volume, as heard with the F5’s in “Dope“, the G#5 in “Oh Happy Day!“, as well as in “See You Again” and “Lost Stars.” The highest he’s ever pushed his falsetto was the Bb5 in the high note battle amongst the BTS members.

Many of Jungkook’s issues lie solely with his lack of understanding of proper breath support and many of his stylistic choices. As addressed by Dr. Iris Stevenson, Jungkook tends to use his throat muscles a lot more than necessary and doesn’t truly allow his diaphragm to expand enough to help him support his singing. If he’d take the time to properly breathe and be more conscious of his diaphragm, he’d be able to maintain a lot more support throughout his voice and thus allowing him more freedom when singing higher. His stylistic choices often have him choose airiness, nasality and softness over powerful singing. This may work for him for the time being, but it also limits him to being able to sing in one specific genre only. Breathiness in singing is perfectly fine if it can be turned on and off at will, however for him it’s become such a habit that he has yet to develop many areas of his voice. His mixed voice, head voice and chest voice all lack proper development and often sound as though they can only be sung in one specific volume output. He tends to sing quietly and smoothly only, which works stylistically but not in every genre. Although Dr. Stevenson addressed his breathing issues, one session alone won’t fix a bad habit he’s created for years.

Although it may be true that Jungkook’s overall voice is not fully developed in terms of technique, this does not take away from the natural qualities he possesses as a vocalist. With BTS’ music, the focus is not on powerful belting and extremely well developed vocalists. Instead their focus is a lot more on smooth and soft singing within a relatively narrow range, which Jungkook delivers very effectively. He may not be the most technical vocalist out there, but the way he sings works perfectly for the type of music he currently sings. When comparing him to the other two tenors of BTS, Jin and Jimin, Jungkook is the most relaxed out of the three. Jimin’s singing tends to be very tight due to issues similar to Jungkook’s, but also a lot of tongue tension. On the other hand, Jin sings with a lot of throat tension even with a relatively low range for a tenor.

Thus it is actually quite clear why Jungkook would be their main vocalist. He is the tenor with the most control of his voice and who’s most relaxed when singing and even though V may be able to grasp breath support slightly better than Jungkook, BTS’ music is not written for a baritone voice. Their music generally stays within the F3 ~ G4 range, which is a relatively comfortable range for a tenor but actually quite challenging for a baritone to constantly be singing in. Thus it makes sense that Jungkook is their main vocalist, as he’s the one who’s most comfortable within the range their music is written in. For the future of his career as a vocalist, Jungkook would need to undergo training for basic singing technique in order to improve his singing. However that would be necessary if he were to take a different road musically and change his singing genre and style drastically. As it is right now, his singing style may be limited but it is sufficient for his chosen repertoire as he stays generally within a comfortable range and doesn’t often abuse his voice by singing outside of his supported range.

Musicianship

Jungkook’s main idea of musicianship usually derives from his idea of the R&B genre, where he tries to add his own musical ideas to songs in the form of vocal runs. As previously addressed, his vocal cords lack the full muscle memory and control to execute his musical ideas as accurately as he intends them to, which usually results in a sloppy pitchy delivery overall, such as the runs in “If You.” However when it comes to other aspects of his style, he has a good sense of knowing when to soften his voice and when to blend his voice with others. Since he usually sings with a softer and mellower tone, he allows his voice to blend more easily with others in harmonies, as heard in “Some” as well as in “You’re My.”

Rating

Weak Vocalist

Vocal Range Video(s)

Video by: Riki Kudo

Best Vocal Performance(s)

Analyzed by Ahmin (Kitsunemale)

Advertisements

About ahmin3

kitsunemale from YouTube, AhMin33 from Twitter and Ahmin from OneHallyu! https://www.youtube.com/user/KitsuneMale

363 thoughts on “BTS’ Vocal Analysis: Jungkook

  1. Jungkook recently went on masked singer. I’d love if you could watch this performance and see if it changes any opinions because I think this is one of his best performances

    Like

      1. Jimin went both sharp and flat. He pushed too much air so his falsetto transition was sharp and then coming back down to his mix, he ended up going lower than he intended too. It has to do with air flow management. As for Jungkook, he used falsetto when he sang above Eb, which was Bb and G.

        Like

      2. We don’t analyze non-Kpop vocalist videos but he’s been overhyped a lot recently from what I’ve seen but I don’t understand why. All I’ve heard from him is strain in his mix and his head voice.

        Like

  2. I think it’s kind of a pity Jungkook was on the most recent episode of King of Masked Singer. A lot of the talented vocalists that perform try to stray from their own “color” and can modulate their voices to fit that style. A lot of the vocalists that get far on the show are the ones that no one can identify because they have become vocal chameleons. Jungkook is Jungkook and identifying his voice came almost immediately after he started singing. A girl reacting to this video basically said she’d know that “slurry” “airy” voice anywhere. I think “slurry” is a great description for his vocal run-ons. He is too young and ill trained to really blow the audience away on that show. BUT, all the girls swooned, so mission accomplished? Another 100,000 copies sold CHA CHING! Oh PD Bang…

    Like

    1. I think the premise of the show is somewhat flawed tbh…but anyway. I think Jungkook did well by picking a song he enjoys, within his range, and doing his best. Personally, I was impressed. Kyuhyun was on the show not too long ago, he’s classed as a near Great vocalist, and he didn’t get any further than Jungkook did. Ryeowook however, who didn’t disguise his voice at all, reached the third round.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. That’s been addressed in both analyses, did you read them both carefully? If so, is there anything written that wasn’t clear enough?

        Liked by 3 people

    2. That’s a really cool point you brought up, but I’d have to disagree. I think fans of any idol would recognize the voice, but the panel and audience necessarily wouldn’t. For example, when Chen from Exo went on, I knew instantly it was him and so did the rest of his fans. But that doesn’t mean the audience did.

      Like

  3. Hi! Thanks for all the great analyses! This question isn’t really related to this analysis but… Who among the male Kpop singers has the widest range? I saw a previous comment that said Kyuhyun, Daehyun, and Baekhyun, but it was about a year old. Has there been anyone else? Thank you!!!!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Well if you check the analyses we always count the number of notes and how many octaves vocalists have. For now Kyuhyun is the only male to have shown a full 4 octave range. The rest all have shown either 2 or 3 octave ranges and I believe others have not shown 3 octaves, 5 notes or 3 octaves 5 notes and 1 semitone yet. So the next step down would be 3 octaves 4 notes and 1 semitone which include vocalists like Sungjae and then 3 octaves and 4 notes which is like V and Ken, then 3 octaves 3 notes and 1 semitone which is like Daehyun and Baekhyun.

      Like

      1. Oh Thank you for replying! Yeah, I haven’t really been up to date with reading all the analyses, though I thought I checked most of them… oh well. I must have read an outdated comment lol.
        Thank you once again. I really love this website!

        Like

      2. Since you find their range off videos etc. Is it possible that you wouldn’t know their like full full range because maybe a particular idol just hasn’t done some high note battle etc.? Especially if it was a really safe vocalist like Kyuhyun they might never reach that high, like I think you got Kyuhyun/Ryeowook’s note from that high note challenge but I feel like they could go higher if they pushed it.

        And omg nice new website the design is more consumer friendly now hahahaha thank you for all your hard work.

        Like

      3. Oh of course, we really don’t know their full ranges most of the time. All we know is their showcased range, which can vary from 2 to 3 octaves but I am 100% sure every single one of these vocalists has a 3 octave range, they just haven’t shown 3 octaves live/in studio. I think for vocalists like Kyuhyun or Ryeowook, we got their peak notes or at least very close to it considering how their D6 and C#6 sounded respectively. But yeah, we can’t know a vocalists full range without sitting down with them with a piano. What we know is what they’ve shown us which for many is their full range and for many it isn’t. For an example, I am sure Taeyeon and Tiffany can sing above C6, Seohyun can sing above C#6, Minzy can sing above F5 and Shannon can sing above G6. Is it really more customer friendly? Well I am glad to hear! haha I was nervous about the change.

        Like

  4. this is a bit random and you may not know im not sure if you’re familiar with her but how is ariana grande’s vocal techniques?

    Like

  5. hello! Thank you for such an in-depth analysis! Sorry if someone has asked for this already, but have you heard Jungkook singing trot (granted they’re all kind of fooling around in this video, Jungkook included) in BTS Gayo Track 8? It’s one of the few times I’ve heard him use his lower register(? I think?), but I’m also definitely not a vocal expert! His part starts at 3:50. Here’s the link: http://www.vlive.tv/video/3948
    What do you think?

    Like

    1. That was already asked about and what I said was that he sounded fine because he wasn’t actually singing that low. The lowest he sang was D3, the rest was fairly normal and comfortable of a range for him.

      Like

  6. Hmm, this is really good, evaluating my biases singing technique. But I would have thought he’d be ‘weak to average singer’. Jungkook sounds pretty stable when he’s comfortable in it but he seemed like the basic singer than what some fans made it out to be. His voice has gotten better from earlier on, in terms that isn’t as shaky as it was before back then. Out of the singer line of BTS it does make sense that he is the main singer because you can manipulate his voice to suit most of their songs most easily than in comparison. For example, I liked how he sounded in ‘Rain’ by BTS but I wondered what you thought about his performance here:

    And in case the link didn’t work, search on YouTube
    2014 BTS LIVE TRILOGY EP.2 : THE RED BULLET – Rain
    Also could you do Park Jimin from BTS? (especially about that end note he let out during ‘Let Me Know’) I’m very interested to see what he excels at and what he lacks in. Thank you very much.

    Like

    1. I’m sorry but we only analyze half of the vocalists in a group and only the half with the best technique. So I’m afraid Jimin won’t be analyzed and considering Jungkook’s rating and the fact he’s BTS’ second most skilled technical vocalist, Jimin’s technique level and rating could only be lower than Jungkook’s unfortunately. The end of let me know, I believe he uses a very pushed falsetto to hit A5. An overview on Jimin is that he has a very weak sense of support, with a lot of tongue tension throughout his range. He tends to sound really tight because his tongue gets tense causing his throat to be fairly closed, aside from him normally using a nasal placement as opposed to a more opened mask placement. What exactly are you curious about that performance? I don’t notice anything different than what was described in the analysis so if you could give me more detail with your question, I could answer better.

      Like

      1. Hi, i’m curious. regarding Jimin’s high note, wasn’t it head voice? he blended it directly into his chest voice.

        btw, if i may ask, do you see any particular improvement in him since then?
        Thanx

        Like

      2. Are you referring to his A5 in Let Me Know? Could you link it to me so I could be sure if it’s head voice or not? No, I have not heard any improvement from any of them unfortunately.

        Like

      3. Yes, i meant the A5. This performance:

        wow, they really do need a vocal coach and training. sorry to take up your time, but may i ask you take a look at this video? it’s a very recent cover they performed:

        Like

      4. It sounds more like a pushed falsetto to me, the A5. You’re not the first to ask about the Without A Heart performance. There’s nothing new about it, it follows everything we know. There’s Joohee’s vocal part in there as well, which someone asked about as well.

        Like

      1. Ah it’s hard with pop singers who get to use reverb it made it sound “echoed” if that make sense and round but did it have good placement?

        Like

      2. Also this may have been dumb of me but I forgot to tell you I have asthma so I’ve been trying to breathe like a normal person would but do I have to do anything differently

        Like

      3. Thanks for answering both questions and my asthma I’m honestly just happy I’m way better than since I was when I was 9 or 10. Do I have to do anything differently or it’s still the same breathing principle. Also is wheesung a good vocalist I was listening to a song from him and I thought he had really good runs.

        Like

      4. Well I’m not sure how asthma affects you, my friend who has it can’t take very deep breaths so she has to breathe a lot more often during songs. Wheesung as in “good” the rating? No. Honestly I’m not sure what his rating would be, but I don’t think it’d be anything higher than average.

        Like

    1. Yeah it’s the same sometimes I feel like I have to take a deep breath but I can’t if that makes sense,so taking a lot of shallow breaths instead of deep long breaths would help?

      Like

      1. Thank you so much. It’s this weird thing to explain where I feel like I have to breathe into my chest but when I do it never feels filled up like I’m still short sorry for my rambling but yeah thanks again

        Liked by 1 person

  7. Could you tell me if Jimin’s C#5s and E5 from 3:50 to 3:54 are mixed?
    I find it hard to distinguish between a heady-mixed note and a thinned-out falsetto in males’ voice :<

    Like

  8. This might be a completely stupid question because I know very little about vocal technique, but here I go…There are a lot of weak vocalists in the kpop world, and I just wanted to know if it’s possible that a lot of them could actually damaging their voice with the technique they’re using (especially if they get a lot of lines in songs and end up singing a lot). I’m guessing it must depend on the specific technique they’re using, but I was thinking that if anyone isn’t singing correctly, it must be bringing extra tension to their voice (which can’t be good). Great blog btw! I love reading it =)

    Like

    1. That is not a stupid question at all! Actually K-pop isn’t the only place where we have a lot of weak vocalists, we have a lot of those all over the world. Singing with improper technique is very likely to hurt your voice and when you’re young, you’re more resistant to damage but the older you get, the less quickly your healing process is. That’s the whole point of our analyses, of course some vocalists do have weak technique but they strain less because they don’t sing outside their comfort zones. Jungkook isn’t at much risk because he tends to sing less challenging lines but someone like Jimin is more likely to damage his voice because he tends to strain a LOT more, because he sings much higher in his falsetto and a lot more often. Someone like Leo is a lot more likely to damage his voice than someone like Sungmin of Super Junior because although both are rated as weak vocalists, Sungmin doesn’t sing songs that take him outside of his comfort range so even with improper technique, he can handle singing lower songs. Leo on the other hand sings VERY high VERY often, which will damage him if he doesn’t fix his technique.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. wow thanks for answering (and so quickly)! That does make a lot of sense, but it does make me wonder if these singers ever really think about or understand what effect they’re having on their voice (or even care about it–which I feel like they should if it’s their occupation for the most part). Anyway thanks for explaining it so well ^-^

        Liked by 1 person

  9. Hello, i just bumped into you blog cause of BTS short film #3 featuring Kim Taehyung aka V. Although I’m not really familiar with vocal techniques all of its terms, I agree with you 100% that V has the best vocal performance among the 4 bts vocals. I’ve watched some of bts live concert in YouTube and one thing I’ve notice is all of the 7 members constantly cover their nose with one finger while singing or rapping. I guessed it is to conceal the breathing sound, but I find it too obvious since blocking the air that comes out of your nose does affect the sound of your voice as a whole. Not sure if you know what I mean.

    Like

    1. I don’t think they do it on purpose since I’m sure most of the time they take breaths through their mouths instead of their noses. I think it’s just a mic habit from watching other rappers and copying sort of what they do.

      Like

      1. This comment is a couple months old, but I wanted to offer some insight to that habit, cuz it’s what I do too. Positioning the finger there helps to keep the microphone at a constant distance from the mouth. When moving around a lot on stage, you don’t want to be hitting your teeth with the mic while you’re trying to sing or rap, or rubbing your lips all over it. So when your finger touches your upper lip, you know the mic is too close. c:

        Like

    1. Hi there! ^ ^ Unfortunately I wouldn’t say so at all. He was very very throaty from the moment he started singing, completely singing using his throat without even attempting to be relaxed nor supported.

      Like

    1. Please read our future analyses list and rules when making requests. It is against our rules to analyze Jimin. We only analyze half of the vocalists in every group and only the half with the best technique. 2/4 vocalists of BTS have been analyzed so I’m sorry but we won’t analyze Jimin.

      Like

      1. I have a question. Will you still include vocalists that have nice technique too even though they may exceed half of the vocalists?

        Like

      2. Include them in the future analyses list? Yes, if you read the rules that question is addressed there. The minimum rating requirement would be like a really high average or an average to above average vocalist. Which is why we analyzed 3 vocalists for SHINee, Brown Eyed Girls and Mamamoo.

        Like

      1. Intonation isn’t a rating, there’s no such thing as average/weak intonation as if it’d refer exactly to the rating name. Good intonation is just a general term and a good vocalist can have off moments, but for them to be constantly off key no, that is not possible.

        Like

  10. Hi ahmin! Just wondering, I read somewhere that Jungkook said he has Rhinitis. Does that contribute to his often airy or nasally voice when singing because he might usually has to breathe through his mouth due to rhinitis?

    Like

    1. Breathing through your mouth is very common for singers and should absolutely no impact on how much you’d place your voice in your nose. That’s sad to hear though.

      Like

  11. Okay this may sound stupid but I don’t know anything about vocals and things like this… But by saying they’re weak vocalists… You mean they’re bad, or that they need to practice more, or what exactly? And idk but to me the way he sings with more breathiness and air is what makes me like his voice more lol I read V’s analysis too and exactly the things you said that are negative are what I like the best lmao I’m just really confused, I’m sorry if I sound rude…

    Like

    1. Well you see we have a criteria in the front page of the blog which explains what we mean in case you’re confused about terms. I mean actually in the analysis we usually describe what they should work on and how they could improve their singing. So what we mean is that they lack skill and need to fix their approach in singing in order to improve themselves and keep their singing healthy so that they don’t damage their voices. It’s not really about what one likes nor preference, though I appreciate his style is what you like about him, singing is a bit more complex than what sounds appealing to the ear if we are talking about technique and skill. You don’t sound rude at all and excuse me if I do, but again it’s not about what you like but what’s healthy and what helps them sing more difficult songs and currently their singing is limited to what you like.

      Like

    2. To add to what Ahmin said, both V and Jungkook tend to sing with an airy style. If a vocalist is able to change their style of singing at will, while actually sounding good, then it proves that they have a good control of dynamics over their voice. However, if they only know how to sing in one particular way, as with the case of V and Jungkook, then they limit themselves as vocalists.

      Liked by 1 person

  12. This analysis is really clear and your website is really good because it actually uses proper terms to classify vocals, I feel like I learnt a lot just by looking through your analysis.

    I know she isn’t a kpopper, but have you heard of Lana Del Rey? I’ve always loved her voice but people say she is a weak singer, I cannot tell she is good or bad, and I was wondering about your thoughts.

    Like

    1. I apologize but I don’t have much of an opinion on Lana Del Rey. Her lower range is actually nice, but she is not a technical vocalist. She is very much focused on her style and so I don’t know how fair it is to judge her singing like that.

      Like

      1. Oh, thank you for the fast reply! I guess it would be hard to judge her, yes. Do you have another website where you judge non-kpop singers? Or do you recommend any unbiased sites that do? I find it hard to find vocal analysis as clear as the ones on this site ^_^

        Like

  13. Jungkook is still very young, so I hope (and believe) that he will improve his technique, so that when/if you update his analysis some day in the future, he’ll rank higher~ I’m really anticipating for that, especially since he has improved a lot since debut so I really believe in him~

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Nobody really asked about this specific video, I haven’t seen this before either. He is using mostly falsetto and parts of his chest voice he has some sense of support.

      Like

      1. ohh thank you for your reply xD
        Can you tell me how to differ the sound that are supported and which are not?and in what sec? i’m sorry to bother you with my stupid question? u.u

        Like

      2. Have you seen our vocal tips series? The second video talks about identifying vocal strain. It should help. He was mostly only somewhat supporting when singing lower and not in his falsetto.

        Like

    1. If Jungkook were to develop his technique he could be as good as SoHyang. If you practice developing your technique and doing good habits there is really no cap on how much you can improve and from what I know about Jungkook he has ample room for growth and improvement it’s just a matter of him taking the opportunity to do so.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. He is hitting quite a few F#4’s, which are outside of his supported range and then 0:24 G#4’s which are even higher. So he sounds quite shaky, his vibrato uneven and yes it is strained.

      Like

  14. Jungkook recently collaborated on KBS Gayo Daechukjae. I’m wondering if that’s “resonance” from 0:26 on? If you have time, could you also tell if the rest of his performance here in any way alters the views in the article? (Once, when he was on King of Masked Singer singing “If You”, you mentioned that it displayed his lower range in a better way than you could have perceived before)
    Thank you for your hard work on this site ^-^

    Like

  15. I agree with the analysis. He’s really not the most technical vocalist out there, but he is actually a good performer, especially considering bts’s songs that aren’t exactly the most vocally challenging. His tone is actually one of my favourite; it is youthful despite being generally unpolished. I just hope bighit actually spends some money and time for sufficient vocal training.

    Liked by 2 people

  16. how do you find this performance? was it too weak? does he use more style over technique to sing this song too? also, there are some vocal runs, i think they were “good” but maybe pitchy?(idk but something bothered me) Lastly, would you say he sings with too much airiness and softness in the first lines?Thank you for your time! Have a good day!!

    Like

    1. There’s nothing in this audio that’s different than anything else Jungkook has shown. This is just breathy singing. A lot of whispering and the higher parts are all fairly tight, squeezed and nasal. He is using a LOT of style in the beginning but the parts where he isn’t airy, he is just using improper technique. He is trying to be powerful, but he is really squeezing his throat. His runs were fairly simple throughout and they were fine, I didn’t think they were pitchy. He barely sang runs honestly.

      Like

  17. What do you think of note sung by Jin in the background at about 1:44? It’s really hard to hear if you don’t wear headphones, but hopefully you can hear it well enough to have an opinion? Would you consider it a belt?

    Like

  18. Hi, this comment isn’t really related to Jungkook. I’m just wondering, will a singer with good technique always sound better than a singer who has bad singing techniques? I’m sorry if this is a dumb question but I’ve been thinking about it for quite a while.

    Like

    1. There’s no correct answer to this question because what is it to sound “good?” That’s usually quite subjective, sounding good to someone with trained ears and sounding good to someone with untrained ears is so different. It also comes down to preference a lot of the time, it depends on how much you know and what you like. Also someone’s tone, if you don’t like someone’s voice, no amount of technique will change that. So sounding pleasant to your ear is your thing, nobody can tell you that you’re wrong. But to answer your question from my perspective, a singer with good technique will always sound more opened, relaxed, free, and in control than one with bad technique. I find that to be “sounding good.” But that’s because I have trained ears.

      Liked by 1 person

  19. you’ve probably already heard this before but what do you think of this note by jungkook?
    From :04 to :15 It’s not a complicated riff, but it’s not pitchy is it?

    Like

      1. No, I said it was tight. Tight is not a good thing, ever. Tight means the throat isn’t opened nor relaxed. The pitch was accurate, that’s the only thing that was technically good about it.

        Like

  20. Hey Ahmim, I been reading a few of your analyses but I was wondering among them if you had anyone that you preferred overall? Sorry if that is a silly question.

    Like

  21. 2:50 & 2:54 Jungkook does some sort of high notes. I was wondering what notes these are and if they’re still as tight(?) and strained(?) as usual? How’s the placement?

    Like

    1. We generally avoid watching performances from weekend shows since they’re full of choreography and aren’t sung with a live band. What do you mean by stable? They have yet to show improvement.

      Like

      1. That is most likely correct, I’m afraid. Although I’d like for you to wait until we actually analyze him.

        Like

  22. I don’t know if you have listened to this song or not, but what is your opinion on Jungkook’s note at 3:25? It sounds really throaty.

    Like

  23. Well, ARMY can not accept this objective review.

    You should see on the Yonghwa column, a weak vocalist does not mean he can not produce enjoyable sound. Their technique are incorrect and the sounds are unnatural.

    Like

    1. I’m not sure I understand your comment since most of the ARMY’s who have read these analyses have been pretty understanding and accepting.

      Like

    2. Dude, I’m an ARMY too but there’s a clear difference between loving your idol and being a deluded and butthurt fan. You have to filter hate from constructive criticism!!! If you can’t handle any sort of criticism against Jungkook, which will actually HELP him grow as a vocalist, then you’re not a true fan I’m afraid. Stop all this unnecessary idolization – nobody is perfect and we ALL have flaws, Jungkook included.

      Like

  24. hey ahmim! wow u answer all questions posted here that’s really cool of u. I have a few question for you of you don’t mind answering
    I noticed that seokjin and jungkook areally airy and nasal I wonder if that could affect their vocals badly in the future
    and recently with spring day it was quite a vocal song was there any improvements in bts’ vocals? do you think big hit knows about their lacking vocals and the flaws in them?

    Like

    1. Nasality doesn’t affect one’s health, but airiness can irritate the vocal cords and can eventually damage them. I don’t know what Big Hit thinks and I have not heard any improvement from them unfortunately.

      Like

    1. Hi hi!! He is not using just one kind of voice the whole time, if I understand what you mean. 1:25 ~ 1:26 that was falsetto but 1:27 ~ 1:28 he went back into his mix/chest voice for a moment. The rest onwards is falsetto, placed in his nose, until the end I think. Only that one second he transitioned down out of falsetto, but the rest was just falsetto.

      Like

  25. From :16 to :24 what do you think of this? He singing with more connection than normal, can it be considered to be head voice during the high parts? Is it placed well?

    Like

  26. i came and read this after listening to one of his covers. fans always talk about how an amazing vocalist he is but the more i actually listened to the song and studied it the harder it was for me to listen to it was because of how breathy it was which is veeerrry his style but he cut the verses off soo quickly his breathing was very loud like veeerrrryy loud and sounded very rushed so i doubted his vocals also cuz i dont hear him sing many very strong and like hard songs and turns out hes a weak vocal but im not that surprised for some reason but i guess its the power of popularity and his smooth voice that made him completely overrated but not saying hes bad just veeerrry overrated

    Like

  27. This will probably sound weird and convoluted. I do not really have an ear for this stuff so unless I’m really really listening for it or someone is completely horrendous I don’t notice a lot of the kind of stuff mentioned. For example Adele sounds fine to listen to I can tell her vocal resonance equates to melodic yelling and it will royally fuck up her vocal cords. I think Jungkook sounds nice so it is a shame his technique is so bad because of how bad it will wreck someone’s throat. I’d imagine his problem was a lot of people told him how good he sounded but no one told him that just because you sound good doesn’t mean you know how to do something properly. Also, don’t these places how voice teachers or some shit? I think the one that taught BTS was interviewed and she was talking about Jin? Shouldn’t a vocal coach be able to hear these things?

    Like

      1. Can these vocal instructors not hear the faults in their students technique because they’re not well trained instructors? Did they not learn how to hear the flaws?

        Like

  28. Hello~

    0:15 What’s that note? And his larynx was lowered, right?
    0:23 What’s that note? I don’t think his larynx is low anymore
    0:36 Unsupported head voice? Or falsetto​? (I think it’s head voice) And what note is that?
    1:06 I’m trying to learn how to hear different types of strain, you said he strains everything above Eb4, so he’s raising his larynx, right?
    1:14 It sounds like his throat is closing? What note is that?
    1:20 What are those three notes? (It sounds like he’s​ pushing them out with his throat)
    1:31 Lowered​ larynx?
    1:45 Neutral larynx?
    3:15 Really strained E4? F4? Lots of throat tension?

    Is there a difference between throatiness and throat tension?
    What were the lowest and highest notes in this song?
    Can this type of straining really damage your voice? Or is it alright for now since Jin is young? (I just realized you and him were around the same age lol)
    I’m curious, what is thmost effective way to eliminate throat tension?

    Sorry for the long post, and thanks for your hard work~

    Like

    1. I LOVE specific questions, it shows me you really are trying to learn and I like it.
      0:15 you mean the note right before the end of the line that came more at like 0:14? Eb3. I wouldn’t say the larynx was lowered, he was just generally really breathy.
      0:23 do you mean more like 0:22? Cause if so, it’s another Eb3. It’s less breathy.
      0:36 unsupported head voice pitchy runs that are more like slides. Bb4.
      1:06 Yes he is and singing from his throat on the G4.
      1:14 A4 before the head voice transition I think
      1:20 G4 Bb4 C5, yes closed throat, lots of strain.
      1:31 I don’t hear a lowered larynx, just no support.
      1:45 Not very different, just a bit louder.
      2:07 Eb4 I already her throatiness here.
      3:15 Oh no, it’s much higher than that. It’s Bb4 G4 C5 Bb4. He sings pretty high in this song, which shows how much of a natural tenor he is …and not a baritone as some fans seem to have believed.

      Throatiness generally sounds rough, husky, like a really scratchy quality, whereas throat tension may be just some form of tension coming from the throat muscles, be it the swallowing muscles, or the glottal muscles, or something we can’t identify too specifically. The range seems to be Eb3 ~ C5 throughout.
      Yes, the way he hits notes above G4 is actually a lot more damaging than let’s say how K.Will hits them. K.Will is a vocalist who likes to sing higher a lot, but because he has a solid basis of support, even if his C5’s may be strained, there’s enough of a basis of vocal cord stretch and support that you can hear he is not purely relying on his throat. Jin is 100% in his throat, there’s no openness, no proper stretch, just pure tension and strain. For now it’s okay, but I would think from the way it sounds, he’d feel at least a bit sore right away. Jin and I are like 3 months apart in age.
      To eliminate throat tension? Singing softly within a comfortable range and developing good habits of being relaxed and quiet without having to rely on pushed volume, air pressure and tension to sing louder and higher. People try to sing high and loudly too quickly and don’t give their vocal cords time to adjust.

      Like

      1. Thank you~
        When you say that Jimin has a very weak sense of support​, do you mean that he uses shallow support rarely, or does he not support at all?
        Do you think that Jimin is going to get a vocal hemorrhage or something of the like anytime soon with the way he’s straining notes in the fifth octave?
        How long does it usually take for bad technique to permanently damage your vocal cords? (It depends on the person, right?)
        Do you know when Jimin starts straining in his mixed voice and falsetto? (I think it might be G4 and C5, but I could be wrong)
        Last one, do you know any idols that have damaged their vocal cords?
        Thanks 💕

        Like

      2. I would say most of the time he doesn’t support almost at all but he’s relatively relaxed within a lower range. As opposed to Jin, where I kind of hear tension throughout his whole range. It’s kind of like Leo, Henry and JYP, vs Jay Park or Niel. I don’t listen to them enough to check where he’s singing range wise and how much he’s straining but since he’s young, I’m optimistic that something like that wouldn’t happen soon. Everyone’s voice is different, some people can handle vocal abuse more than others. So there’s no set time we can determine for people. Jimin strains as low as E4/F4, or has more tension than he is relaxed. Idols who have damaged their vocal cords? Idols who have had vocal nodules include Kyuhyun, Tiffany, Onew, Hyorin, Jonghyun, etc. Some people may have good technique but their previous abuse when they were young may have an effect on their voices now or not resting and being super busy with their schedules also takes a toll on their voice. There are multiple factors that affect vocal health.

        Liked by 1 person

    1. I believe Jimin sings with a lot less throat tension, even though there is tongue tension, breathiness and tightness, within a lower range he’s a lot more relaxed.

      Like

  29. sayingV is better than jungook means u r drunk of hallucinating
    V barely made it to bts and he CAN’T sing .
    while j ungkook sings most of their songs and their lines for a reason ..they know better . he fits everything and he can do anything
    they give V lines as just being part of the group
    they take advantage of j ungkook !
    V? he is just their to make them 7
    j ungkook is the only one fitted to be successful as solo artist
    do u really believe V can be successful as solo ? my a*s he could be kicked out but not a solo .

    Like

    1. At first I was going to respond to say that we don’t like comments that are hateful and immature and I was going to ask you to read the analysis, then I realized you’re the same person who’s been posting under the username “Lili” and “Sam” saying a lot of positive things about V and how he has the strongest support and he’s underrated as a baritone, now you write a comment like this and I am so confused as to why. Perhaps you’re the one who’s drunk or hallucinating?

      Like

      1. Well I changed that opinion , sorry to confuse u , but really he doesn’t sound like he can sing at all ,
        And I was defending him at first but he really doesn’t worth it
        I saw a thread that made me change my mind , again , I was really defending but after the Japanese video he sounded better but different ..

        Like

      2. Your comments were literally 15 minutes apart, you changed your opinion in 15 minutes? It’s okay to change your opinion subjectively but to bash V and make hateful comments about him, like you can prefer Jungkook and not be hateful. So if you’re going to be immature, please just stop commenting. We don’t support hateful immature comments on this blog.

        Like

  30. Trust me , if î could delete the comments I supported him I would , but again all I said is true , really , in all terms jungkook sounds a lot better , I thought V was better but really live ? It doesn’t sound like it

    Like

    1. Babykook, you need to stop letting yourself get influenced by what others think all the time and think for yourself. ASAP!!! Those two lads work hard and one of them sings in a range completely outside of his comfort zone, and yet still manages to have some support, an accomplishment by itself. Instead of putting them down, find another hobby.

      Liked by 2 people

    2. dude how old are you that you can’t eve use correct grammar? just because a person is the main vocal line does not mean they are the strongest vocalist. just take bigbang or got7 for example. Taeyang(BB) is the main vocal line but daesung definitely has a more powerful voice and JB(Got7) is a weaker vocalist than Youngjae.

      Like

  31. If these “vocal instructors” were not taught to hear the faults in a vocalist’s technique, wouldn’t that mean they’re not practical as teachers? I mean I know some of the people at the kpop companies who give lessons are not trained/certified vocal instructors.Sometimes they’re performers who used to be in a group. There’s Jang Jin Young from BlackBeat who’s now a voice coach at SM ent who was on the Unnies show, but I don’t know how much he knows about technique in particular, let alone if he was trained in it. I apologize if this might’ve come across as rude.

    Like

    1. Did you perhaps read the analysis? Because the answer to your question IS the analysis. This isn’t an analysis about his voice, this is an analysis on his vocal technique. If you personally like his voice and you think it’s one of the best you’ve ever heard, that’s perfectly fine and nobody can tell you that you’re wrong. Because that’s to do with taste, not vocal ability. He is a weak vocalist on standards based on his vocal ability and his vocal technique, which is clearly explained within the analysis, so why don’t you give it a chance and read it?

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s