E3 ~ G5 (2 octaves, 1 note and 1 semitone)
A3 ~ C5/C#5
- Support is present throughout the voice
- Able to support her mixed voice up to C#5
- Lower range shows support down to A3, occasionally G#3
- Transitions into falsetto are smooth
- Intonation is mostly accurate
- Runs are produced with relative smoothness and flow
- Resonance is produced with consistency up to C5/C#5
- Diction is too speech-like, vowel shapes aren’t as opened as they could be
- Most closed vowel tends to be Ah (아)
- Support below A3 is almost inexistent, voice becomes very soft and airy
- Mixed voice above C#5 generally lacks power and becomes tight
- Larynx raises above C#5
- Unable to sing in a head voice
- Runs can become sloppy when too complicated and not carefully thought through
- Lower register: Support is consistent down to A3 and occasionally some support can be carried down to G#3. Generally sings with a very soft and airy chest voice below A3.
- Mixed register: Able to produce resonance with varying degrees of openness due to closed vowel shapes. Above C#5 tends to sound throaty or very tight with a high larynx.
- Upper register: Not ever shown the ability to sing with a head voice, but does generally well with falsetto transitions. Tends to sing only with an airy falsetto and the limit of her falsetto range is still unknown.
Although mostly promoting as a ballad singer, Ben’s agility is not completely overlooked nor underdeveloped. She has shown more than a few times that she has the right amount of muscle coordination in her vocal cords to allow runs to flow with relative smoothness, as heard in “눈, 코, 입” and “천일동안.” However, her voice still lacks full control and flexibility when doing runs, as she often becomes somewhat pitchy and loses the rhythmic flow as runs get faster and more complex, as heard in “다시 사랑할 수 있을까“, “You Are My Everything” and “키도 작고, 예쁘지 않지만.”
Originally Ben debuted in 2010 as the main vocalist of the female vocal trio Bebe Mignon, dubbed to be the female version of 4Men. With a relatively successful debut, the group’s career was short lived and after the departure of member Gaeul, they disbanded. Her mentor, Vibe’s Yoon Minsu, did not let her talent go to waste and Ben soon debuted as a solo vocalist. As a soloist, she’s been recognized as a powerful vocalist despite her height, about 147.5 cm tall or 4’10”, she is always able to impress those around her as a tiny girl with a big voice. She’s been a guest on TV shows such as Yesterday and Immortal Song 2 where she has made a name for herself as a powerhouse vocalist.
The lower portion of her range is by far the most neglected and under explored part of her voice. Her chest voice generally carries tone down to G3, but support is only truly present down to A3, as heard in “사랑으로” and “천일동안.” There have been occasions where some support was carried down to G#3, but most of the time her voice becomes fairly airy and soft the lower she sings. This is due to her vocal cords not coming completely together as she descends in range, causing her chest voice to be unable to project or be produced with much tone as she sings lower. This can be heard in the G#3’s in “만약에“, “사랑으로“, G3’s in “사랑합니다“, “한숨“, F#3’s in “인연“, “갈색 추억“, F3’s in “Let It Go“, “늦은 후회“, and E3’s in “거위의 꿈.”
Her mixed voice is the area of her voice where Ben is able to showcase the most control and power. Consistently being able to place her voice correctly in her mask, while also supporting properly with a good balance of chest and head voice muscle development in her mixed, she’s able to sing through her mix by producing resonance. This can be heard whenever she sings within a comfortable part of her supported range, where resonance is produced with fulness and power up to C#5, as heard by the Bb4’s in “My Love“, B4’s in “J에게“, C5’s in “그대는“, “알고 싶어요“, and C#5’s in “잠시만 안녕“, “내 인생은 나의 것” and “파도.” When she also holds back on the volume output, she is able to carry support up to C#5 as well with more ease, as heard by the C#5’s in “인연.”
Ben’s main issues in her mix voice usually have more to do with her vowel shapes than issues with support. While support is carried up to C#5, she has the tendency to enunciate overly clearly with a more speech-like versions of vowels, as opposed to creating easier versions of vowels to sing. In singing, it’s common to alter the sounds of vowels in order to allow for them to be in the most opened spot in the throat, allowing for a shape that’s more opened and relaxed. Ben tends to close her throat a lot even when carrying support and resonance, which causes her to sound tight even within her supported range, as heard by the C#5’s in “갈색 추억“, “거위의 꿈” and C5’s in “Fight Song.” This mostly happens on the Oh (오) and Ah (아) vowels. Above C#5, her larynx raises and she’s unable to carry support, even though she has produced resonance up to D5 as heard in “J에게“, she mostly strains in that range. This can be heard with the D5’s in “그대는“, Eb5’s in “Let it Go“, “갈색 추억“, E5’s in “오늘은 가지마“, “지나간다“, “우리들의 이야기“, F5’s in “잘해준 것 밖에 없는데“, “바람기억“, “사랑은 언제나 목마르다“, F#5’s in “사랑으로“, “두근구든“, “내 인생은 나의 것” and G5’s in “Tears.”
Her upper register is produced as a falsetto. Ben has yet to show the ability to sing with a connected head voice, instead opting for an airy and soft disconnected falsetto. With the ability to produce a head voice, she has yet to develop her head voice muscles properly. As a result, her muscles are used to her simply singing with a half closed approach where a lot of air still tends to pass through her vocal cords in her upper register. Nonetheless, her transitions into her falsetto are generally quite accurate in pitch and she tends to sound mostly relaxed up to F#5, as heard in “눈, 코, 입“, “이별 10분 전“, “꿈처럼“, “만약에“, “그 남자, 그 여자” and “천일동안.” The true limit of her falsetto register is still unknown, as she might be able to sing much higher than F#5.
Her overall ability and technique are quite adequate. Ben may show issues with tension, but within her supported range she tends to sound very strong and full. Her control of dynamics are quite well shown when performing ballads, as she’s able to sing with the right approaches to fully convey the message of songs. For future improvement, working on proper vowel shaping to open up her mix could benefit her and give her a lot more freedom in her mixed voice. Also working on her head voice and chest voice could allow her to sing a much wider repertoire of songs.
Mostly working as a soloist throughout her career, Ben has very few chances to showcase her ability to harmonize. Nonetheless, she’s shown that when it comes down to it, she’s able to blend her voice well and handle her parts when singing duets and harmonies. When it comes to musical changes in songs, she tends to add very subtle and minimal changes that are often well executed within her supported range in terms of pitch, but outside of her supported they still carry a lot of tension, as heard by her run in “천일동안” as well as her musical changes in “거위의 꿈.”
Above Average Vocalist
Best Vocal Performance(s)
Analyzed by Ahmin (Kitsunemale)