Vocal Range
D3 – C6 (2 octaves and 5 notes)
Supported Range
G#3 – Eb5
G#3 – A5 (with head voice)
Voice Type
Soprano
Strengths/Achievements
- Nasality is almost never present in her singing
- Sings with a very balanced mix with even resonance up to Eb5
- Well developed head voice
- Good control of her voice in her supported range
- Can transition into head voice without difficulty
- Strong, healthy vibrato is almost always present in her supported range
Points for Improvement
- Notes above Eb5 in her mixed voice are usually shrill with a high larynx
- Vibrato on notes above Eb5/E5 is often laggy and uneven
- Notes below G#3 are usually unsupported and accompanied with a low larynx
- Notes at the top and bottom of her supported range can have stability issues
- Head Voice becomes tense and tight above A5
- Compared to the rest of her voice, her lower register is considerably less developed
Registers
- Lower register: Her weakest register by far. Supports well down to G#3, below this she stops supporting and loses proper larynx position. Tone either becomes airy or forced.
- Mixed register: Well balanced with bright, even resonance up to Eb5 and occasional good placement on E5. Well developed and even outside her supported range good placement is kept even if the support is lost.
- Upper register: A very developed head voice with good control up to F#5, and resonance up to A5.
Agility
Despite being a lyric, Yeonji does not have a very agile voice. Often times, Yeonji will attempt runs that often come out without pitch accuracy and an unclear melodic idea, as in “If I Ain’t Got You” and/or lose power and projection even in her supported range, such as in “The Last“. Stylistically speaking however, Yeonji is more of a ballad singer and does not generally attempt complicated vocal embellishments nor the addition of vocal runs and instead opts for a more dynamic approach and her highly acclaimed high notes.
Overall analysis
Former main vocalist of Seeya, and the newest rookie of Immortal Song 2, Yeonji is known for being a very good and well respected vocalist. Yeonji has always stood out as the one member in Seeya with the biggest sound, something that comes from her naturally larger sound input in her instrument and a more womanly tone, indicators of her fach as a Full Lyric Soprano.
Being a soprano, Yeonji overlooked developing her lower register and as such it is her weakest register becoming unsupported with a lowered larynx below G#3 and at times losing stability below Bb3/B3. Oftentimes her voice becomes unclear and muffled below G#3, such as the E3’s in “정“, or just forced out with a low larynx, such as the E3’s and D3’s in “If I Ain’t Got You“. Around and above G#3, her tone is a lot more present and generally she is able to project with a much more stable and well placed sound, such as the G#3’s in”이젠 그랬으면 좋겠네” and A3’s in “가슴 아파도“.
Her mix voice, however, is developed very well being balanced all the way up even outside of her supported range. Being a very trained register, she is capable of producing a large, even resonance as shown by the B4s in “나 가거든” , the C5s in The Last, the C#5s in “넌 또 다른 나” and the Eb5s in “꿈에“. Unfortunately, Yeonji loses proper technique above Eb5, pushing her larynx up causing a very notable lose of projection and resonance as well as an uneven vibrato resulting in strained E5s such as in “”이젠 그랬으면 좋겠네“” and F5s in “남남북녀“. This isn’t to say that she loses support around E5, on the contrary, she remains quite well supported even up until then. However due to her bad habits and unnatural vibrato, she tightens up her throat and closes the sound with a high larynx due to her vibrato when singing above Eb5. Despite this, she is able to vocalize in that range without much fatigue even belting up to G5, demonstrated in “Tears“, though this has a much more strained, pushed sound compared to when she vocalizes in her supported range, such as in “나 가거든“.
To compliment her well developed mix, Yeonji has also trained her head voice rather well. Yeonji shows great support and control being able to transition from a belted B4 into a crescendo E5 in “나 가거든“, to effortlessly floating up to F5 and F#5 in “잃어버린 우산” and producing a large, resonant A5 such as in “Musical“. Once she goes above this, there is tension causing the notes to become shrill and thin as heard in her C6, such as in “그래도 좋아“.
Musically, Yeonji is not much of a show off vocalist and doesn’t try to sing all over her range. Instead she is a very sensitive vocalist who conveys her emotions well through the user of proper dynamic approaches, accompanied by an amazing control of her breath support, allowing for very smooth crescendos and diminuendos, alongside a very healthy vibrato. Her setback in this case is the lack of support she has in her upper mixed notes that she relies on a lot, which could damage her if done too often.
Yeonji’s ability as a vocalist has gained her the respect of many, opening up a school for singing that taught hundreds of students who flocked there because of her name alone. Yeonji has made a name for herself by singing well along the likes of Davichi, T-Ara, and even Brown Eyed Girl’s JeA and shows a goal to continue her life in the world of music. Even after her departure from Seeya, Yeonji has proven that she’s nowhere near the end of her music career nor vocal career.
Musicianship
Yeonji has a good ear, knowing how to properly convey feeling in her vocal performances. Despite this, she does take a lot of risks when singing such as vocalizing out of her supported range and attempting runs that she is unable to handle, exposing her weaknesses as a vocalist and leaving out her ability to fully control the more musical and experimental part of her sound as a musician/vocalist.
Label (Type of Vocalist)
HV Vocalists: High Head Voice Vocalists
MB Vocalists: Mid-Range Belters
ML Vocalists: Mid-Low Range Vocalists
WR vocalists: Well Rounded Vocalists
Vocal Range Video(s)
Video by: chung2F5
The Eb6 in the video is a C6*
video by: Pedro_0508
Best Vocal Performance(s)
—
Analyzed by Haruko & Ahmin
(Originally analyzed by Gangertae)
” after her departure from seeya, she has proven that she’s nowwhere near the end of her music career nor her vocal career” so sad to hear that, she doesn’t sing well as she was a member of seeya
LikeLike
That’s not what the part you quoted said….
LikeLike
No.. it says she’s not leaving, she’s here to stay. Also she’s about as good as she used to be.
LikeLike
I miss Seeya and SG Wannabe. How would you rank Kim Jin Ho as a singer?
LikeLike
I heard their recent comeback mini album actually. I am not sure how he’d be ranked but probably from what we heard, he wouldn’t be rated as “good”. Not sure yet though.
LikeLike
Thanks for the reply. I think his vocals is damaged now with the way he sang over the years. His vocals were so much better during the early years when he debuted.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I should definitely check on that, I’ve never really kept up with his career.
LikeLike
I was wondering if she was regressed…
LikeLike
She did not, she was always the same.
LikeLike
back then I used to think that she was pretty consistent up to E5 until her recent performances on programs such as IS. Well my ears weren’t working well then
LikeLike
Her E5s have good placement, so perhaps you just heard that and confused it for resonance. Don’t be too hard on yourself, you were close^^
LikeLike
Interesting that you put 나 가거든 among her best vocal performances, because I just listened to Jung Eunji’s version of it yesterday. I wonder how she did in this?
LikeLike
It’s funny that you asked, I was just listening to Eunji’s version(again). She did really good, those B4s ❤
LikeLike
I think Yeonji was consistent up to E5 and resonant F#5 in the past . I’m afraid that she doesn’t resonant well as she did . She goes down now
LikeLike
No no, that was a misconception. She never really had resonance or support on E5 or above. Maybe good placement, but not support.
LikeLike
In her old analysis, some one ranked her as a good vocalist and her supported range up to E5 . I don’t understand if you say her level hasn’t changeable . Is it really a mistake??
LikeLike
It was a mistake, she never had E5, it was the fault of the previous analyst.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow, I didn’t know and never heard her before. I do now. Instant fan, here.
Plus she’s a full lyric, a rare breed in Kpop, omg. Anyway, I don’t know if you guys have been asked this before, but is there any particular reason that full lyric vocalist hasn’t really stood out in Kpop over the years?
LikeLike
Actually, quite a few full lyrics are popular or very respected in Korea(Yeonji, Lee Young Hyun, Sohyang, Eunji, JeA, Solji, etc). I think Full Lyrics are more rare to see in girl groups than as ballad or solo artists because most girl groups go for cute approaches whereas most Full Lyrics in Girl Groups have more mature, womanly voices that are used for sexy concepts.
LikeLike
Yeah that’s what I was getting at, none of those nice vocalists actually hailed from the big three agencies (four if you include FNC). I don’t know, for me it’s just a shame.
LikeLike
I mean SM is the only company from the Big 3 with good vocalists but yknow they have a LOT more artists, so the probability is much higher.
LikeLike
Meanwhile JYP has this habit of kicking away nice vocalists, HA!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
JYP admits that he doesn’t like “amazing vocalists” but instead “vocalists who’s singing voice is the same as their talking voice.” So that says a lot about him.
LikeLike
JYP really said that? Not that his MAMA 2015 performance helped giving him a positive image… (the second hand embarrassment is too real).
LikeLike
hello ad, can you watch this video? I see having some high notes in this video
LikeLike
You mean this video right? Yes she has high notes in this video. Next time, make sure to add a time stamp when you ask a question like this just to make sure. ^ ^ 3:20 F5 high larynx, 3:30 F#5 high larynx 3:51 and 3:55 F5’s with a high larynx. Those high notes were outside of her supported range, everything else was around Eb5/D5 and below, so she did well except for those specific notes.
LikeLike
sorry ^^ because this video has a lot of high notes which i can’t add time
LikeLike
hello ahmin, can you watch this video at 3:01? Is the E5 resonance?
LikeLike
Hi there Mimi. It is not resonant, it’s strained. The larynx was high but the mixing is nice.
LikeLike
hello ahmin, Can you wacth this video in 0:10 where she has high notes? Is it resonance?
LikeLike
I think it is just supported and has vibrato but not resonant. Resonance should have “bell-like” sensation or whatever you call it. LOL
LikeLike
Careful with your answers, it’s better if you wait for us to reply sometimes.
LikeLike
Yes it is quite well placed, resonance is produced throughout the phrasing of the notes she was singing.
LikeLike
There are Eb5 and D5 in 0:10, right?
LikeLike
Yes yes
LikeLike
hello admin, can you help me in 3:28, 3:31, 3:33, 3:48 and 3:56?
thank you.
LikeLike
What’s your question?
LikeLike
can you check in this video?
LikeLike
3:33 3:48 were E5’s, 3:56 was F5 all strained, high larynx and pushed out. The rest were good.
LikeLike
E5 is good, right?
LikeLike
No it’s sung with a high larynx and throat tension.
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, can you watch this video in 1:47, 2:49, 3:03 and 3:30? thank you very much.
LikeLike
They’re all E5’s into D5’s, except for 3:03, that’s only D5.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So they’re resonance. ^^
LikeLike
The D5’s yes
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, can you watch this video in 4:40, 4:45, 4:55, 5:11. thank you very much. ^^
LikeLike
4:40 Resonant Eb5, 4:45 strained high larynx F5, 4:55 strained E5, 5:11 somewhat high larynx E5 but much better than the other one, the placement was really good.
LikeLike
So she has improved, right?
LikeLike
No, see’s more or less the same but sounding good. The E5 might indicate something.
LikeLike
How do you judge this artist? I think she isn’t worse than Yeonji. 🙂
LikeLike
So Chanwhee? The original singer of the song? She doesn’t really produce resonance in her mix, at least not here. She’s a rock singer and she sacrifices a lot of technique for that gritty and screechy quality in her mix. It’s hard for me to say Yeonji isn’t better because Yeonji has a much healthier approach to the song, she would drown her out not only for being a Full Lyric but also for having a much better approach that allows bigger resonance and healthy support. So Chanwhee doesn’t support Eb5 or anything above, so Yeonji seems better to me so far.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hello ahmin, at 4:35, 4:42, 4:51, 4:55, 5:05, 5:21 have high notes. Can you check for me? Thank you very much.
LikeLike
4:34 C5 ~ Bb4 ~ G#4, 4:42 C#5 4:51 Eb5 4:55 F5 5:05 E5 5:21 E5 again. Nothing new everything above Eb5 was strained and even the Eb5 had some tension but with support, it was just somewhat shrill and shaky. She’s inconsistent with Eb5 so it’s nothing new.
LikeLike
Ahmin, you check for me!!! Thank you.
3:57, 4:01, 4:12, 4:28.
LikeLike
3:57 tense Eb5, too much throat. 4:01 Eb5 and F5, also too much throat, high larynx. 4:12 high larynx, really throaty E5. She sounds tired on those upper notes, usually she can strain them with less tension. 4:28 another strained E5. Nothing new here.
LikeLike
What do you think about the other See Ya vocalist? i forgot her name…
LikeLike
Unfortunately I am not familiar with Boram.
LikeLike
Ahmin, you check for me!!! Thank you.0:52, 1:30, 2:04, 2:48, 2:52, 3:07, 3:09, 3:32, 3:39.
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, check for me at 3:19, 3:24, 3:33, 3:43, 3:48, 3:51. Thank you.
LikeLike
3:19 resonant C5 3:24 resonant D5 3:33 strained F#5 3:43 again strained slightly flat F#5, again at 3:48, 3:51 strained A5, never heard her mix an A5 before though that threw me off lol
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, check for me at 2:36, 2:48~2:51 head voice? 3:20, 3:34, 3:48, 7:21,7:56 and 8:00.
thank you very much.
LikeLike
2:36 resonant head voice F#5, 2:48 F#5 to A5 in head voice again resonant. ^ ^ 3:20 resonant C#5 3:34 strained F#5 3:48 another strained F#5 7:21 7:21 another resonant C#5 7:56 and 8:00 a few more resonant C#5’s. ^ ^ No problem dear.
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, check for me at 3:14, 3:35, 3:50, 3:54.
thank you very much.^^
LikeLike
3:14, 3:50 and 3:54 strained E5’s, 3:35 resonant D5. ^ ^
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, check for me at 4:09, 4:39, 5:27, 5:34.
thank you very much.^^
LikeLike
4:09, 4:39 strained E5’s, 5:27 could be more opened, Eb5. 5:34 F5 to Eb5 back and forth, could be more opened as well.
LikeLike
and this performances 2:50, 2:53, 2:57, 3:00, 3:10. thanks. ^^
LikeLike
Resonant Bb4, D5, C#5, strained F5 and resonant D5 with a bit of closedness in the throat in the end.
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, check for me at 4:19,4:25, 4:34, 4:50.
thank you very much.
LikeLike
4:19 supported Eb5, could be more opened, 4:25 strained F5, 4:34 strained E5, 4:50 strained and flat E5.
LikeLike
hello ahmin, who is better?
LikeLike
Yeonji has better technique in her mixed voice than Jungin.
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, check for me at 2:55, 3:00 and 3:02
thank you very much.
LikeLike
The notes were E5, G5, and E5. The first two were a very well projected head voice. The E5 had pretty good placement but I’m not sure I’d say the larynx was neutral.
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, check for me at 4:07, 4:12, 4:22, 4:38.
LikeLike
4:07 support and placement are present, but the larynx was slightly raised and I heard a bit of tension. 4:12 high larynx F5, 4:22 4:38 high larynx E5’s.
LikeLike
Hello ahmin, check for me at 0:20, 3:05, 3:18
and 3:28, 3:39. Thank you very much.
LikeLike
0:20 resonant C5, 3:05 and 3:18 until that vibrato kicked in, I would’ve called Yeonji’s E5’s supported but then the vibrato closes her throat a lot.
3:28 high larynx F#5 3:39 tight, vibrato is tightening the throat for the E5.
LikeLike
So Yeonji has improved in E5? ^^
LikeLike
I’m not sure if she’s improved or if she could always support E5 but let her vibrato get in the way.
LikeLike
and this one, 5:23, 5:39, 5:45, 6:14. thanks ahmin so much. ^^
LikeLike
All of them are C#5’s, the last one was the only one with a closed vowel but she opened up and despite the vibrato, they are a lot fuller and open than E5’s.
LikeLike
ahmin, check for me 4:00, 4:02.
and this 3:28, 3:43, 4:11. thank you very much.
LikeLike
4:00 I’d say the E5 was tight but the 4:02 D5 was much more opened and relaxed. 3:28 nicely placed D5. 3:43 resonant C#5 4:11 well placed phrased and supported Eb5.
LikeLike
So the E5 has supported?
LikeLike
No it was not.
LikeLike
I listened to her ost in “I’m not a robot” and she doesn’t sound girly, definitely a full lyric.
LikeLike
hello ahmin can you analysis this song, please? and I heard high note from 3:00 to 3:40 but it’s a audio not live. thank you very much.
LikeLike
A lot of very well placed C#5’s and D5’s is what I hear.
LikeLike
Was the B5 or Bb5 at 2:50 tense? The Eb5s from 3:45 to 3:50 were resonant? I know that the F#5 and G5s right after we’re strained but how about the placement?
LikeLike
It’s a Bb5 and it seems quite pushed with good connection and placement, but too much air pressure, not enough proper stretch and support. 3:45 The Eb5’s are well placed but the vowel causes tension so there’s less freedom. And the F#5’s and G5’s are as usually, very well placed.
LikeLike
hello ahmin, this is the song in the Yeonji’s liveshow. Can you analysis this song, please?
at 3:44, 3:58, 4:16. Thank you so much.
LikeLike
hello ahmin, this is the song in the Yeonji’s liveshow. Can you analysis this song, please?
at 3:44, 3:58, 4:16. Thank you so much.
LikeLike
We already got your original comment, we just couldn’t respond yet so it’s left for approval.
LikeLike
Ohhh so can you watch the video?
LikeLike
Not now which is why I left the comment up for approval so I can respond when I do have time.
LikeLike
“A very developed head voice with good control up to F#5, and resonance up to A5.” So she has less control above F#5, but still able to produce resonant till A5? Don’t you need a good control to produce resonance? Wait, isn’t A5 higher? I’m sorry if I sounded dumb, i’m uneducated lol.
LikeLike
I wasn’t the sole author of this analysis but I agree with you and will check with the author to understand what they meant. Edit: I checked with the author, they meant the control of her dynamics, she is less controlled but still able to keep resonance up to A5.
LikeLike
I did not write this analysis but what I believe the author is trying to say is that up to F#5 she is very consistent with her resonance and control, but above that there can be resonance however inconsistency with like support, placement, “Control” etc. You don’t sound dumb it;s fine.
LikeLike
hello admin, I want to ask about Yeonji’s F5. it’s strain or supported?
at 2:33
and 2:38. Thank you so much.
LikeLike
they are very strained…
(high larynx and pushing)
LikeLike
hello ahmin, long time no see. I want to ask for the E5 at 3:35 and her head voice at 3:22.
I hope that you will reply me. thank you so much.
LikeLike
Hi ahmin. I want to ask about this performance of YeonJi.
She hit many high notes from 3:10 to the end of the video.
So she supported them or strained? Thank you so much.
LikeLike
The video is unfortunately blocked for me.
LikeLike
hello ahmin, this is YeonJi’s new songgg. How do you feel?
this is new MV:
at 1:07, 2:15, 2:58
and this
at 1:05,3:05 and 3:48
I heard some E5 from her. thank you so much.
LikeLike