D3 ~ Bb5 (2 octaves and 4 notes)
A3 ~ C#5
Strengths & Achievements
- Strongest vocalist in Wonder Girls
- Able to support her voice with consistency up until C#5 mostly
- Somewhat developed mixed register with good placement at times
- Able to support some of her lower range and keep some vocal tone
- Supports most of her mid range
- Able to keep resonance up until D5’s at times
- Has been able to produce a fuller cleaner head voice
- Shown good improvement from debut to present
Points for Improvement
- Although some performances can be pitch accurate, intonation isn’t always on point
- Occasional nasality present in some notes
- Uses mostly an airy falsetto
- Not consistent on D5 and above, tends to raise her larynx and close her throat
- Low notes tend to be very breathy and lose cord connection more often than necessary below A3
- Squeezes her falsetto the higher she goes with shallow support
- Runs can often be sloppy and lazy
- Voice can lose laryngeal openness thus becoming very small
- Lower register: Able to keep stability in tone and projection down to Bb3/A3 consistently, at times able to keep her support down to G#3 but losing projection and volume. Her voice then will tend to get quieter and breathier the lower she gets, although keeping tone present down to F#3/F3, the vocal cords lose connection with too much air coming through.
- Mixed register: Consistently resonant and well supported up until C5, very often resonant on A4’s, Bb4’s and B4’s. Can at times support her range up until D5, keeping resonance up there occasionally. Her voice is developed with more stability in pitch and projection in this register.
- Upper register: Her head voice is mostly not used, very occasionally happening. Oftentimes can be sloppy when switching into falsetto, at others being impeccable and with correct pitch. Up until F#5 she is able to stay relaxed, but anywhere above that seems to become tight and unsupported.
Sunye possesses a light soprano voice, which makes runs easier for her. She oftentimes sings runs in her performances, but they lack pitch accuracy, meaning her notes are hit, but they’re mostly done by sliding from note to note, rather than hitting every note precisely and individually while connecting through the runs. She also may get pitchy with her runs, but mostly they just sound lazy and sloppy, needing work on precision. An example would include Wonder Girls’ 두고두고 where at the end of the song Sunye hits F5 and descends in a run, which sounds uneven and unclear, sliding through the notes in a rather clumsy manner.
Sunye stands out from the Wonder Girls due to the natural color of her tone. She possesses a very beautiful and unique instrument, her voice is very bright and feminine, with a lightness and clearness that make her voice always sound rather angelic. She’s always been the main focus amongst the Wonder Girls members, by focusing not only on singing, but also on dance and being the leader. Her level of skill right before she debuted and as soon as she debuted has changed overtime and she’s shown considerable improvement.
Sunye’s lower range possesses a clear tone that is kept from her voice as a whole. She oftentimes sings down in this range around A3 and higher, keeping good cord connection and tone production. When she descends below that, however, her support drops along with her cord connection and volume. She gets very airy on the notes below G3 losing focus and projection and consistency. Sometimes she’s able to produce clearer notes in that range, but many other times more air than tone comes out when she sings on a range around F#3 and below. Examples would include her OST song Maybe, where her F#3’s are at times produced and clearly heard, although very quiet, and at other times mostly air comes out.
Her mixed register is one of the healthiest ones amongst K-Pop vocalists, when she supports it. She tends to generally use a very healthy bright balanced mix with a nice opened throat and resonance throughout her C4 ~ C5 range, where she has most control and her voice shines more. Even though she is able to support lower notes, the fourth to fifth octave is where her soprano voice sounds most comfortable. Sunye’s case is interesting because when the Wonder Girls debuted, she would struggle hitting notes as low as C5 and B4 and would strain her voice, close her throat and get considerably flat and tight. Overtime however, she has learned how to place her voice correctly to produce fuller, better supported notes in that mid-high register when she often stays resonant.
The range starting from C5 and up tends to get tricky for her, however. She has been able to stay supported and even resonant on notes around C#5 and D5, she’s often supported up until C#5, but when she gets to D5 her throat agains starts closing and her larynx starting raising. She’s not able to keep an even mix as she ascends, causing her to push her voice and letting her sound thin out as she ascends higher. Her mix however is still well balanced enough that she is able to belt up until G5 more consistently than many other female vocalists without cracking, however so, with improper technique and a high larynx.
Sunye has at times been able to produce a head voice and switch into it with clarity and skill, but more often than not, she uses a breathy falsetto to sing in her upper register. She does not possess a throaty falsetto and generally stays very relaxed in it, without struggling or tiring her voice out too much. The breathiness in it, however, still is damaging to the voice as it irritates the vocal cords by drying them up as too much air goes through them. When she ascends higher above F#5, her throat seems to close and her higher falsetto notes sound rather pushed and tight. Her runs in falsetto are also like her runs in the rest of her range, lacking real clarity and accuracy in pitch, example being her peek highest note in When You Believe. The Bb5 then descends down where her throat was closed hence causing the run to sound clumsy and lazy.
One of Sunye’s biggest assets is her vibrato. It’s often used and consistent anywhere in her range. It comes off very relaxed and consistent in speed, where it always adds stability and clarity to her singing. On the other hand, one of Sunye’s biggest flaws is her intonation. It’s more often than not where Sunye will go slightly off or flat in a performance. She has some performances where her intonation is clean throughout the whole performance, but many other times she will go flat and get pitchy when trying to pull back in volume, showing a lack of true breath control when trying to add dynamics to her songs. Many times she’s able to sing softly and powerfully, but at other times she will let her pitch get slightly wobbly and shallow in tone production.
Interestingly enough, Sunye’s pitchier performances are often in English, showing that perhaps her pitch is directly affected by her lack of confidence in the language she’s singing in, such as covers of Christian songs she tends to sing in her Church, which are the most recent performances Sunye has with her singing. Whenever she gets to sing a Christian song in Korean, however, her pitch and stability are much better, having a more forward placed voice with resonance and consistency of tone production up until C5/C#5.
Her intonation although at times very clear, can be slightly wobbly due to the lack of a true support in her voice and confidence or preparation in her songs. Her runs and melismas also lack true clarity in tone and her voice loses in terms of creativity. Sunye however still shows an adequate level of musicality by playing with breathiness, brightness and mixing when singing. She can at times add a little bit of nasality to her singing by softening her mix, but is also able to open her throat and lift her soft palate in the same song when wanting to sing more powerfully, showing that her slight nasality is more due to a dynamic choice rather than a lack of ability to stay resonant.
Sunye is a vocalist who during the debut had trouble keeping her larynx stable even as low as B4 and couldn’t produce true resonance due to her throat being closed and her laryngeal space being compromised. Her pitch was often off and she would have trouble switching between falsetto and mixed voice, causing her to go flat and pitchy. Throughout her career, however, she has learned how to place her voice and stay resonant. Two very notable performances include her performance of You Raise Me Up, where she shows true power in her voice with resonant C5’s and C#5’s. Even so in that performance, notes above D5 lost stability in her larynx position, it shows a great improvement from her debut. Another example would be a recent 2014 church performance of “그 사랑” where she shows minor pitch issues, with consistency in tone production up until C5 as well.
She doesn’t try to sing outside of her comfort range often and is a clever vocalist, knowing where she can truly control her voice. To further develop herself as a vocalist, learning how to place and develop her mixed voice above C#5, opening her throat and keeping a more stable support to keep herself from going flat should be areas to focus on. Another area should be separating notes when doing runs, which could greatly improve her ability as a vocalist.
Sunye’s interpretation of songs include occasional melodic changes, although subtle, they exist. She doesn’t try to add too much and has a safer singing style, not showing much vocal creativity when it comes to interpreting and covering songs, but also not trying to do things she isn’t able to properly.
Label (Type of Vocalist)
MB Vocalists: Mid-Range Belters
Best Vocal Performances
Vocal Range Video(s)
Video by: kitsunemale
Analyzed by Ahmin (Kitsunemale)
46 thoughts on “Min Sunye’s Vocal Analysis”
She sounds more like an Above Average-Competent vocalist.
I thought that at first but her intonation really drags her down… If it wasn’t for that Id have put her in that level
Hi, can you share which are some of her better live performances? Thanks!
Would u like the links to be on the analysis u mean? Cuz they’re the 그사랑 and You Raise Me Up
Sorry for asking a stupid question, but what is intonation?
don’t worry, it’s not a stupid question. At times I used the term interchangeably hoping people could grasp the meaning. Intonation means basically pitch, so having good intonation means being on pitch.
She seems more like Above Average to Competent. I like her melodic changes.
Which Wonder Girls’ song is most suited to her voice?
I can’t honestly say what song is most suited to her voice. It’s not like f(x) where their music barely ever showcases Luna’s vocal ability, WG songs have enough challenges here and there.
I disagree she would only be in between if she was more constantly resonant and she isn’t and if her intonation was so wobbly so often. She gets flat on easy lines way too often and it’s more than just bad days. I thought she was in between till analyzed her fully, with 2 average registers, not much agility and one in between register it really doesn’t make her in between.
I have been asking around, but noone seems to give me an answer. Could you tell me how’s her performance in this collab? Is WG suitable for such performances?
Okay 1. Sohee’s voice doesn’t project. Yoobin can’t control her pitch nor breathe correctly, her voice was just not stable at all. Lim shud not sing. 2. Sunye sang alright but it’s not her thing and it didn’t showcase her much 3. YeEun cant belt as well as she thinks she can, so many of her random belts were kinda just…messy and meh. so.. this wasn’t good really but it felt very badly rehearsed and divided
That makes Sohee sound not bad. Anyway, was wondering if you could also do for Yeeun, Lim and Sohee sometime? I know Sohee isn’t known for her vocals, she is nowhere near the top, but I have heard very divided views of her vocals. Like sometimes she can do it very well given certain type of songs.
Well Sohee does well sometimes FOR her level, not like well as the general idea of well. I will definitely do YeEun when I make her vocal range video, but I’m sorry we have to first get through main and lead vocalists first, meaning even if they’re average or weak, we have to get through them first. Sohee and Lim don’t classify as vocalists, only sub vocalists. We already know they’re at least average if not worse.
I really can’t arrive to check the criteria section !
I can’t find it on the blog
It’s like on the first place it says home, about and our criteria.. Unless maybe my friend was editing it actually so perhaps you won’t be able to view it till the editing is done, so I’ll make sure we will finish that ASAP!
It’s been completed, thank you too!
Would Sunye be considered better than Yeeun? I have a feeling that she might be but I’m not too sure.
Yes yes no doubt she is better than YeEun but not by a whole lot
What do you think about 2PM’s vocal? Jun.K especially? I have always been curious but it seem like people here doesn’t really care about them
Well nobody in 2PM really stands out vocally, they’re all pretty weak or average vocalists, I’ve heard Junsu mess up really bad and I’ve heard him strain a lot, live he seems also very nasal like when I saw him in person and he pushes notes out with his throat a lot.. to me he seems average but he may be a bit better like average to above average?
Really? Wow then there must be a lot of difference between them and 2AM right? I heard Jun.K was supposed to debut with 2AM at first but ended up with 2PM so they will have a main vocalist.
Btw, you really have met them before? Who else you’ve met? ^__^
2AM and 2PM are VERY different vocally, 2PM has Jun.K and that’s it, Wooyoung and Junho really can’t hold much, 2AM has 4 guys who can hold a solo album… oh whom I’ve met? Well lemme try to remember, I’ve seen SHINee, SNSD, TVXQ!, f(x), Super Junior, EXO, Crayon Pop, 2AM, Teen Top, G-Dragon, Dynamic Duo, Yu Seung Woo, DJ Koo, Henry, Lena Park, Infinite, Baek Ji Young, Sistar, 2PM, CN.Blue, 4Minute, G.NA, B2ST, Orange Caramel, Joo Hyunmi, Song Sohee, Girls’ Day, Kim Tae Woo, Gavy NJ and maybe 2 or 3 more I can’t remember right now.. lol
YOU ARE SO FREAKIN LUCKY YOU SHOULD BE FREAKIN GRATEFUL lol you have met pretty much all of my bias groups why so luckyyyyyy >< I'm sorry xd anyway thanks for your respond 😉
Haha no problem
I HAVEN’T EVEN BEEN TO A KPOP CONCERT OR ANY CONCERT(except those crappy school ones
that are barley concerts)!!! You’re amazingly crazy! I have been peforming in front of thosands of people dancing my whole life but that’s not a concert. Are they a lot of money? WOW AHMIN, JUST WOW!!!!!
Not really a lot of money, I went to a few free ones too lol
If she is AA, shouldn’t Taeyeon too AA but not competent. They seem pretty even, even that Taeyeon is better.
I think taeyeon is AA to competent instead, she has more consistency with resonance and stuff~ theyre not far though
Reblogged this on Thariamon, M.D..
Have you even done an analysis on a first generation idol group? If you haven’t I can suggest these. Bada from S.E.S or Lee Hee Jin, Shim Eun Jin and Kan Mi Youn from Baby V.O.X, Baby V.O.X especially. I sometimes find it hard to pin down which of those three has the best voice, some fans have said that the best voice Mi Youn while other fans say it’s Hee Jin. Can you end this little dispute have please? Thank You
You should check our future projects when making this kind of request. Bada is going to be analyzed. We don’t talk about who has the best voice in this blog, we talk about vocal technique, I hope you know the difference. They shall be taken into consideration but current material would be necessary. I am not familiar enough with Baby V.O.X. to tell you.
I would like to ask a question. Is Sunye or Taeyeon a better singer?
There are analyses on both Sunye and Taeyeon with ratings at the end and a criteria in the front page. I don’t mean to be rude but the answer is there in the analyses.
I’ll go check that out. BTW, your didn’t seem rude at all.
LikeLiked by 1 person
(idk where to post this so i’ll just ask here) can you say who are the strongest to weakest female AA vocalists? i think it’s Wheein > Solar > Bohyung > Narsha > /Hyorin/>Solji/>Minkyung > Sunye > JeA I’m really not sure about Minkyung… but i think Sunye and JeA are the weakest out of AA, am i right?
Weakest? Jea yes, Sunye no. I’d rather you just wait for our chart come out. ^ ^
Oh I didn’t know a chart is coming! (Also I forgot Hwasa and I just noticed that lol…)
LikeLiked by 1 person
what do you think about this performance? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTlCTBae6VA
She sounds nice, a bit too much air is being pushed when she sings, like she aspirates a bit too often. 0:54 her Aye vowel is tense, while the Oo vowel is nice, cause her You Are notes are B4’s and those were more relaxed than the 0:54 B4. Her accent can make her sound a bit nasal. Her low notes aren’t bad. I am very happy with her B4’s, they’re really nicely mixed and supported. She is not pitchy in this either. The range is G#3 ~ B4 until 2:26 C#5 there, she sounded fine, a bit tight but the oo vowel is a bit of work. 2:40 C#5’s, after the key change. 2:48 flat C#5, 2:54 off key, she sang D5 but I am pretty sure it was supposed to be D#5. 2:55 E5, I’m not sure that was supposed to be. She got a bit pitchy after the key change but otherwise technically she was fine. The pitchiness was lack of practice with this song more so than lack of technique. She did well for the most part, she’s stayed pretty much like what I’ve known of her.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2mlk1VrnzI just curious have you ever see this?
sound nice to me haha
I think I have lol
hahah, i just missed her so bad lolz
can you analyze this performance? Thank you
What are Sunmi tier and supported range?